Beyond the Hamptons, Discovering Charm and Timelessness in Shelter Island

Shelter Island captures a quaint, chic timelessness — an ode to the effortless glamour of a Kennedy summer.

I was lucky enough to visit Shelter Island after some friends invited me to visit them. The trip was nothing short of spectacular and left me completely enchanted. Shelter Island has a charm and essence that make you feel as if you've stepped back in time. Before diving in, I want to take a moment to thank my very dear friends for introducing me to this incredible island — just a five-minute ferry ride from the Hamptons, yet in my opinion, far more beautiful, serene, and refreshingly uncrowded.

The Pridwin stands magnificently on Crescent Beach, a gleaming white landmark that honors summer traditions while providing all the comfort modern travelers crave. Yes, Gwyneth Paltrow is a regular, but celebrity sightings are just a pleasant bonus to the real attraction — a genuine coastal experience that remains wonderfully unspoiled.

You come for the tranquility that the Hamptons sacrificed long ago on the altar of scene-making and status. Here, that precious commodity — authentic peace — is still abundant, wrapping around you like a comfortable blanket from the moment you arrive.

The rooms at The Pridwin balance classic charm with contemporary comfort, offering that rare luxury of waking up to water views that instantly recalibrate your sense of what matters. Recent renovations have only enhanced the property's warmth and welcoming atmosphere without losing its soul.

And the food — my god, the food. The kitchen embraces the bounty of surrounding waters with a reverence that's evident in every bite. Seafood tastes transcendent here, prepared with a confident simplicity that lets the quality ingredients speak for themselves. Every meal feels like a quiet celebration of place and season.

Daytime offers endless pleasures. The beach beckons with pristine sands and gentle waves, while the hotel's stunning pool provides the perfect alternative for those who prefer chlorine to salt. Both options deliver that essential summer alchemy of sun, water, and absolute freedom from ordinary concerns.

As evening approaches, Sunset Beach Club delivers exactly what its name promises — spectacular twilight views paired with expertly crafted cocktails. The short trip down the road (by foot or quick Uber) transports you to one of the island's social hotspots without losing the intimate feeling that makes Shelter Island special.

Mornings bring their own quiet delights. Marie Eiffel Market serves coffee and pastries so divine they qualify as legitimate reasons to get out of bed, while Eccentric Bagels crafts the perfect chewy, crusty foundation for whatever morning indulgence you crave.

What elevates Shelter Island beyond a mere vacation destination is its community. Unlike the transient nature of the Hamptons, this island fosters genuine connection. Residents speak of their home with pride and affection, creating an atmosphere that welcomes visitors into something that feels remarkably like belonging.

The Pridwin doesn't just offer accommodation — it offers access to a vanishing America, one where summer still means something profound and restorative. In a world increasingly detached from authentic experiences, this island sanctuary delivers the real thing — a place where you can breathe deeper, smile more easily, and remember what vacation is supposed to feel like.

For anyone seeking the perfect summer escape that combines luxury without pretension, natural beauty without crowds, and genuine hospitality without affectation — you've found your paradise. The Pridwin on Shelter Island isn’t just a great alternative to the Hamptons; it’s the upgrade you didn’t know you needed.

The pridwin: Visit their Website